After the ‘ real life’ Martha from the popular Netflix series Baby Reindeer was interviewed by journalist Piers Morgan, the show has again come under fire. Internet detectives first located Fiona Muir Harvey, 58, and recognised her as the “real” Martha from Richard Gadd’s autobiographical novel Baby Reindeer. Fiona Muir Harvey then claimed to be the character, speaking with Morgan and the Scottish Sun.
The identification of Harvey and the police’s participation following a false accusation of a guy being Gadd’s “real” abuser have raised concerns about Netflix’s protection policy. Since a Scottish MP questioned Netflix’s assertion that “Martha” was found guilty and sentenced to prison, the show has continued to garner attention. A top Netflix executive testified before the Commons Committee last week that the show is safeguarding; however, if it cannot be demonstrated that Fiona Muir Harvey was found guilty and sentenced to prison, the SNP’s John Nicolson warned that their remarks might amount to contempt of parliament. This content explains the history of Baby Reindeer and the reasons behind the program’s controversy.
Comedian Richard Gadd wrote the autobiographical Baby Reindeer just for the Edinburgh Festival. The show, which made its Netflix debut on April 11th, explores Gadd’s allegations that he was the target of a woman’s stalker after she sent him over 40,000 emails and hours’ worth of voicemails. The show also shows her returning to his house, place of employment, and stand-up shows. In the show, Gadd plays a stalker who has been convicted of following an MP and his family in the past and who seems to be dealing with complicated mental health difficulties. In the episode, Martha also confesses to stalking Gadd in court. She is subsequently found guilty of the crime and given a nine-month prison sentence. “Television stalking is often highly sexualised.
It exudes mystery. Someone is in a dimly lit alleyway. Gadd described the character as a beautiful and ordinary person who gradually becomes odd in a press release for Baby Reindeer. However, stalking is a mental disorder. I was determined to portray the intricacies of stalking humanely, unlike anything I had ever seen on TV. It is an unconventional stalker tale. A cliché is taken and turned completely upside down. Gadd’s story covers not only the problem of stalking but also his experience of being sexually assaulted by an older TV writer in the profession (played by actor Tom Goodman-Hill and written as the character “Darrien”).
Netflix did have to deal with ethical concerns of producing the show as a “true” narrative once it became popular, and internet sleuths quickly discovered the “real” Martha’s identity. The show is currently Netflix’s most-watched series. Viewers have questioned if the massive streaming service went far enough to conceal the identity of someone who is said to have severely distressed Gadd in addition to having complicated mental health problems. Benjamin King, senior director of public policy for Netflix in the UK and Ireland, stated that the corporation had taken “every reasonable precaution” to hide the true identities of characters in the show during a speech to the Parliament’s Culture, Media, and Sport Committee on May 8. “Baby Reindeer is an extraordinary story, and it is a true story of the horrific abuse that the writer and protagonist, Richard Gadd, suffered at the hands of a convicted stalker,” stated King.
“We did take every reasonable precaution in disguising the real-life identities of the people involved in that story in the making of the show while also striking a balance of veracity and authenticity of Richard’s story because we did not want to anonymise that or make it generic to the point where it was no longer his story because that would undermine the intent behind the show.” This week, Jon Nicolson of the SNP announced that he had written to Netflix, requesting confirmation of the entertainment giant’s assertions that the stalker who served as the inspiration for the fictional character was found guilty. “It is evident that the evidence provided by Netflix to the select committee is contested,” Mr Nicolson told the BBC. The accusation—that is, a conviction—is crucial.
Fiona Muir Harvey denied that Gadd’s portrayal of her was accurate during her first on-screen interview with Piers Morgan on his TalkTV program Piers Morgan Uncensored. She said she had never given Gadd a call and had just sent him a “couple of emails,” implying that they had exchanged fewer than ten emails. She also denied attending several comedy events and hitting up his girlfriend. However, Morgan’s interview with Harvey has generated criticism of whether or not he ought to have granted such a prominent interview to a potentially vulnerable individual.
Sign up to receive our email, delivering the latest stories straight to your inbox.
